21.8 C
Muzaffarabad
Sunday, November 22, 2026

A Conductor, a Father of Three: Who Was Tayyab Khurshid, Reported Killed in Panjera?

Community posts identify Tayyab Khurshid as a father of three and a Toyota van conductor. Residents allege he was hit by gunfire in Panjera; the circumstances remain unverified.

Hussain Kot youth dies after succumbing to injuries sustained in Rawalakot

Ehtisham, from Hussain Kot and the only brother among five sisters, has died after sustaining injuries in Rawalakot, according to Sada-e-Haq Kashmir News.

JKJAAC Takes AJK Rights Campaign to International Media Amid Renewed Tensions

The JKJAAC Advisory Council says it briefed international media on AJK’s rights movement as Amnesty International, UN experts and HRCP raise concerns over civic freedoms, detentions and the need for dialogue.

AJK’s Political Crisis: Three Reciprocal Steps to Break the Deadlock

Commentary | By Dr Javaid Hayat Khan | 12 November 2026

Pakistan-administered Azad Jammu and Kashmir (PaJK) is facing a dangerous political stalemate involving three principal actors: the Government of Pakistan, the Government of PaJK and the Joint Awami Action Committee (JAAC). None appears willing to retreat for fear of being seen as politically weak. But the longer the deadlock continues, the deeper social divisions may become and the further the resolution of public grievances may recede.

Breaking the impasse requires more than temporary or superficial measures. It calls for political judgement, mutual recognition, institutional accountability and a credible negotiating framework that allows all parties to engage without abandoning their legal responsibilities or core positions.

The political Catch-22

Demanding that the JAAC end its sit-in before negotiations begin is unlikely to resolve the stalemate. The committee has indicated its willingness to negotiate, but the state has appeared reluctant to engage directly through a formal and credible process.

According to reports cited in the debate, almost 100 people have lost their lives during the wider period of confrontation. JAAC leaders face a difficult dilemma: ending the movement without being able to show supporters that meaningful talks and practical progress have begun may be politically and practically difficult.

The full human cost must be acknowledged. Protesters have been killed, while law-enforcement personnel have also been killed and injured. Recognising losses on both sides neither diminishes public grievances nor absolves any party of responsibility. It should instead reinforce the need to prevent further deaths and establish the facts through an independent process.

Governments, meanwhile, cannot reasonably be expected to accept every demand unilaterally without reciprocal commitments. Making the end of the sit-in a precondition for talks risks creating another obstacle. Questions such as the sit-in’s conclusion and the JAAC’s proscribed status could instead be addressed as confidence-building measures within a broader negotiation process.

The central problem is that each side is waiting for the other to move first. The way forward lies in simultaneous, reciprocal steps that allow all parties to reduce tensions while preserving their dignity.

State authority versus the use of force

Every government has a constitutional responsibility to maintain public order and protect citizens. Demands for democratic rights do not remove that responsibility. But maintaining order through the rule of law is fundamentally different from imposing control through sheer force.

  • Rule of law: Maintains public order while protecting citizens’ rights. Government legitimacy is strengthened by justice, transparency and public trust.
  • Use of force: Relies on coercion and pressure to impose order, while treating institutional legitimacy and public acceptance as secondary concerns.

A state does not become stronger by suppressing disagreement. Its authority grows when citizens believe that laws are applied fairly, institutions are accountable and peaceful expression of grievances is protected. A mature democracy treats peaceful dissent as a normal part of political life, not as treason. Protesters, in turn, have a responsibility to respect the law and pursue their demands peacefully.

Restoring the writ of the state in PaJK should therefore mean rebuilding public confidence in institutions, protecting civil liberties, ensuring legal accountability and addressing public grievances—not simply re-establishing control through force.

Three reciprocal steps to end the deadlock

Rather than expecting one side to surrender first, both sides should take gradual, coordinated steps to rebuild trust.

Steps for the governments of Pakistan and PaJK

  1. Establish a credible negotiating framework: Announce an empowered and representative negotiating committee with a clear mandate, timeline and authority. The PaJK government should lead the political process, with Islamabad supporting discussions on matters involving the federal government.
  2. Temporarily pause legal action: Introduce a time-bound pause on new protest-related legal proceedings and arrests. This could create a more conducive environment for dialogue without granting unconditional immunity.
  3. Establish an independent inquiry commission: Form an impartial commission to investigate events in PaJK since 5 June, including deaths, injuries, use of force, arrests and the conduct of all parties. Its task should be to establish the facts, determine responsibility and recommend appropriate compensation for victims.

Steps for the Joint Awami Action Committee

  1. Form an empowered negotiating team: Appoint a formal team to prioritise demands, distinguish immediate confidence-building measures from long-term reforms and participate constructively in negotiations.
  2. Commit to peaceful de-escalation: Reaffirm the principles of non-violence and agree to phase out the sit-in after formal talks begin and initial confidence-building measures are put in place.
  3. Help implement an agreed roadmap: Participate actively in joint working groups to develop and monitor a clear plan addressing governance, economic justice, fair distribution of resources, civil liberties and political representation.

The principle is straightforward: no party should demand complete trust before taking the first step. Each should take a credible action that makes it easier for the other to take the next one.

This would not amount to surrender by any side. It would provide a shared way out of the Catch-22.

The 12 refugee seats: one part of a wider crisis

The 12 seats reserved for refugees in the PaJK Legislative Assembly are an important constitutional issue, but they are not the sole cause of the current protest movement. The wider crisis is rooted in structural problems, including economic hardship, governance reforms, fair distribution of resources, civil rights and the nature of the relationship between PaJK and Islamabad.

The refugee-seat issue requires serious and creative discussion. It should, however, be addressed as part of a comprehensive political settlement rather than allowed to overshadow all other public demands.

The Muzaffarabad Agreement of 4 October 2025 provides an important foundation. Reactivating its dispute-resolution mechanism could offer a practical starting point for negotiations and wider reforms.

The way forward

Genuine political leadership is not demonstrated by prolonging a stalemate or forcing an opponent to retreat. It is demonstrated by finding a path towards lasting peace while allowing all sides to preserve their dignity.

PaJK does not need a political settlement in which one side wins and another loses. It needs an agreement that restores public trust, protects constitutional rights, strengthens the legitimacy of state institutions and addresses the grievances that brought people onto the streets.

The ultimate test of leadership is whether a solution can be built in PaJK without forcing any party into humiliation or defeat.

About the author: Dr Javaid Hayat Khan is a political science researcher and author. His book, Azad Jammu and Kashmir: Polity, Politics, and Power-Sharing, was published by Oxford University Press.

Editorial note: This article is an English-language adaptation of the Urdu translation supplied for publication. The original English commentary, “PaJK’s Catch-22: Three Reciprocal Steps to Break the Deadlock”, was published by Kashmir Times on 2 November 2026. The views expressed are those of the author.

You Might Also Like

In Case You Missed It

Most Popular Articles